I wanted a teal eyeliner and didn’t really want to spend a lot of money. I’ve never used Elf’s eyeliner pencils before but I figured for only $1, I didn’t have much to lose. I really like the Elf Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Pen, so I was hoping I’d have the same sentiments about this pencil.
The top line was my initial swatch. The bottom line is where I went back and forth two times to build the intensity. It’s a pretty color.
It was more difficult applying to my lower lash line for some reason. I had to go over it a few times. It’s almost as if the color wasn’t sticking. 🙁
So I was curious about the staying power of this pencil. I quickly found it that it sucks. I was able to wipe off the liner with my finger with one swipe. 🙁
Well, at least the sharpener works.
I’ve always considered Elf Cosmetics as either hit or miss. There are products that I love from them and then products such as this eyeliner that I regret purchasing. I’m so glad it was only $1. Maybe if I use a primer 1st, it’ll hold up better. What can I say? You get what you pay for. *sigh*